Skip to content

Imagine approaching retirement and receiving the following call about your super.

“…if there’s an economic crash tomorrow, the chances of you losing a big chunk of your [existing] super are quite high. But if it’s spread over a more professional fund, one of the big bank funds or something like that, they’ve got access to between 600 and 1000 different investment options…”

This is a recent real conversation between a telemarketer and a prospective client, which ASIC released as part of its report into lead generation advice models. Sometimes a regulator’s report does more than catalogue a problem. It makes the solution impossible to ignore.

ASIC examined 15 financial advice licensees and their representatives using lead generators. The findings expose material weaknesses in the controls used by some advice licensees and serious safety risks for consumers.

The lead generation model is both simple and complex. You see an ad on social media or receive a call offering a “free super review”. Your details are captured and passed into a sales funnel, where payments might be made to the telemarketer to convince you to switch your super.

ASIC’s findings show just how dangerous that model has become. It describes potentially misleading statements, weakness in licensee oversights, and cases where unlicensed lead generators were performing activities that went well beyond simply finding prospective customers. And it found commercial incentives for lead generators to refer clients to partners, in some cases calculated at 80% to 100% of the consumer’s upfront advice fee.

ASIC’s review follows the devastating collapse of Shield Master Fund and First Guardian Master Fund, where approximately 12,000 people lost more than $1 billion in life savings. Many had been advised to invest after first being approached by a lead generator. But instead of diminishing in the light of the scrutiny that comes with scandal, these practices are, if anything, more prevelant and more dangerous now.

For millions of Australians, super will be the second biggest asset they ever own. And because super contributions are compulsory, Australians should be able to expect particularly strong protections around who is allowed to target those savings and how.

In August, the Federal Government proposed banning unlicensed real-time communications about super, tightening consent requirements for those contacts, and strengthening safeguards around lead-generation arrangements, while carving out safe and legitimate communications.

ASIC’s latest findings expose a fundamental problem: the risk sits in the business model itself. Regulation that focuses principally on whether the lead generator is licensed or precisely how a consumer is contacted risks leaving ways for essentially the same harmful model to continue.

That points to a cleaner solution. Define it. Exempt legitimate activity. Ban the harmful lead generation business model.

A carefully drafted prohibition can protect legitimate workplace super communications, education and advocacy while closing off the business model that financially rewards businesses for funnelling Australians towards switching their retirement savings.

And Australians want stronger action. Recent consumer research commissioned by the Super Members Council found four in five Australians surveyed on social media support an outright ban on lead generation. More than 70% said they found it difficult to distinguish between a scam and an advertisement from a reputable source.

Consumers scrolling through their phones should not need to become financial-services compliance experts to work out whether the person promising to “review” their super has their interests at heart.

Australia has built one of the world’s largest pools of retirement savings, giving millions of Australians a substantial nest egg of their own to support them in retirement, built up over their working lives through our compulsory super system. The bargain that sits underneath that system is simple: if Australians are required to save, we should do everything to keep those savings safe.

ASIC’s report provides Parliament with evidence of the risks. Now it should act on them.

Close the loopholes. Protect legitimate financial advice and communications. And shut and bolt the door on harmful lead generation for good.

Share this article
LinkedInXFacebook
Subscribe to be notified of 
updates directly into your inbox